I can't believe it's taken me so long to not only learn about but try Andy's Pizza out! It's a quality pizza by the slice joint that you can also get full size pies, chicken wings, chicken tenders, and salads from. Nobody told me about the lemonade situation. I ordered the strawberry lemonade thinking nothing much of it and was shocked with pure childlike delight at the sight of the lemonade in a 24oz plastic kitchen storage container! It was a feast for the eyes and for the tastebuds as well since it tasted perfectly balanced in terms of sweetness and tartness. Don't sleep on their Old Bay Fries. They are crisp, seasoned well, and massively portioned for the price - great for sharing. I'll stop in to get a slize of pepperoni, but I much prefer to be able to get a whole pie of the Diavolo. Their generosity in the calabrian ricotta make this a unique tasting pizza that's good fresh, reheated, or cold. The ceasar salad isn't anything over the top, but it is a large, reliable salad if nothing else to help balance out the heaviness of everything else on the menu.

great pizza, great vibes, service is amazing the host max was awesome !!! i'd you're ever in old towne def come check this place out

Don't how I forgot to miss writing this review. Went to this place because was craving pizza while on vacation. It was so good we came back on separate day to bring to relatives. What I love was the ambiance where you can quickly drop in and grab a bite. You could also go on date here. It was on my favorite list this year and I still think of when I am craving pizza.

You're gonna go back for seconds - just unbelievable pizza, every pie is outstanding.

Great Old Town neighborhood joint. Delicious slice and you can buy a bottle of wine at retail price. Highly recommend!

They have very friendly staff and the lady who helped me was very kind. I had the margherita slice 5/5

Seriously though, everyone that works here seems to have the BEST energy! If you've had Andy's before, then you'll know that across the varied locations there if a lot of consistency in the food - delicious, thin, crisp pizza (that you can get by the slice!) However, this location blends in perhaps a little too much into the neighborhood because I've never ever noticed it driving by. Heck, even when I searched "pizza by the slice" I was shocked to see Andy's was just a 4 minute walk from where I was. And even with directions I second guessed them when I first turned onto the street because there just isn't a ton of signage. But as soon as I walked in I was greeted genuinely and enthusiastically by a number of different employees so much so that I told them they have amazing energy! But as always, the pizza hits so I'm glad to know I can easily grab a quick slice whenever I'm out in this direction!

Andy's pizza is amazing! I think one of the best in the area imo and I've had my share! :-) Great texture, robust flavor, and very thin like NY pizza. So good, I ordered two pizzas! I went with the white pizza and margherita.

Honestly probably the best pizza I've had, period. Great dough and fresh toppings. I think they only have one size, which should probably be enough for 3 people. Gets pricy with delivery but well worth it. Looking forward to the next one.